Skip to main content

MAYBE HAPPY ENDING on Broadway

 

All photos by Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman 
and feature Darren Criss and Helen J. Shen

"Maybe Happy Ending" is the most charming musical to come to Broadway in a long time. Is it perfect? No. But what a breath of fresh air to have a beautiful, fully original new musical with a fantastic score that's sure to become a musical theater staple. It find it telling that, more and more, the best new musicals are no longer coming from the U.S., but from overseas. "Maybe Happy Ending", written by Will Aronson and Hue Park. Though Aronson is American, and Park was in America when he first got the idea for the show, it was originally produced in South Korea, in Korean (one wonders if, in the bureaucracy that is American commercial musical theater if such a gem ever would have gotten out of the development stage, as many brilliant shows never do.) Becoming a huge hit it is now on Broadway at the Belasco Theater starring Darren Criss and fantastic newcomer Helen J. Shen (I have to say, as much as I loved Shen's performance I absolutely adore the original South Korean Claire - Jeon Mi Do, especially her physicality. I highly recommend checking out her performance on YouTube.) Michael Arden's direction, as always, is pitch perfect - I especially loved how he combines projection and high tech scenic design (finally used well! Not just as a crutch) with traditional storytelling techniques (fireflies, anyone?) 


"Maybe Happy Ending" is like if Pixar adapted "Never Let Me Go" or "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind." Set in a not so distant future in Seoul where A.I. has advanced to the level of human passing full time personal assistants (with competing models, not unlike iPhones) called Helperbots. The story follows a model 3 Helperbot, Oliver (Criss) and a model 5, Claire (Shen) who live at a facility for "retired" (read: abandoned) Helperbots to live out the rest of their days until they eventually stop working (we watch a montage wherein Oliver discovers replacement parts for his model have been discontinued, and Claire discovers that her battery is failing - barely holding any sort of charge anymore.) Oliver, reminiscent of little orphan Annie, believes that his owner is coming back for him and flat out dismisses the idea that he's been "retired." Never mind the fact that it's been over a decade since his owner left...

His stable, routine world is upended one day when Claire knocks on his door desperate to borrow his charger before she "dies." He ultimately decides to lend it to her, letting Claire into his life and beginning to raise all sorts of questions for both of them about the meaning of their lives and how much emotion they might be capable of. Oliver has been collecting cans at night to trade for money (which Helperbots are not allowed to have) to save up to take a trip to Jeju island where his owner is, theoretically, waiting for him. Claire, realizing that her "death" is imminent, and remembering the beauty of seeing fireflies with her owner on Jeju island, points out several flaws in Oliver's plan, and offers to help by driving them to the island (unlike model 3s, model 5s can drive, and Claire's owner, guilty about abandoning Claire, has left her her car.) 



Much of the story is taken up with the Jeju road trip which features possibly my favorite song in the show, "The Rainy Day We Met" in which Oliver and Claire, realizing they need to come up with an alibi that will allow them to pass as human, concoct a story about how they became a romantic couple (why they are on a trip to Jeju.) Claire teaches Oliver about fireflies, Oliver teaches Claire about Jazz. Claire secretly takes a look at Oliver's memories when he is powered down and realizes that Oliver was indeed abandoned... his owner isn't coming back for him. Oliver promises not to fall in love with Claire (as if robots COULD fall in love in the first place.) Claire warns Oliver that relationships and emotions aren't as straightforward as he'd like to believe, revealing the reason she was abandoned is because her owner's boyfriend fell in love with her. There is a truly magical number where Claire and Oliver dance with the fireflies, and a heartbreaking moment when Oliver learns the truth of what happened to his owner... and how his owner's son feels about Oliver. 

Claire, who had intended to let herself "die" alone amongst the fireflies, instead goes back to Seul with Oliver... and the two discover that they've fallen in love with each other.


If it sounds like I'm giving away a lot... I'm not, really. Because the heart of the show comes into play once the two characters have fallen in love. See, their story, like all love stories, really, is, in a way, doomed the moment it starts. Both Claire and Oliver know with exact precision the moment they will stop functioning... Claire has, maybe, a year... Oliver, possibly three. Which means that Oliver will have to watch Claire die... and then live on without her. And the ultimate question becomes - is it worth it? Both Claire and Oliver end up in possession of their passwords, which gives them the ability to edit their software. They can erase each other from their minds. And, really, wouldn't that be better?

The title of the show comes from the eleven o'clock number of the same name. The lyrics are:

The ending's not the most important part
But as endings go, ours is not so bad
No tears, no regret, no broken heart
And sure, no memories of what we had
But maybe letting go
And moving on
Before we make a mess -
Is that a happy ending? 
More or less

Those sunny afternoons you spent with me
They'll still be happening, just somewhere in the past
Each simple moment was a luxury
They're not less valuable just 'cause they didn't last...
And if nothing else
We fell in love
Not knowing we could fall -
Is this a tragic ending?
Not at all

And maybe we'll meet again sometime
Sometime, when we're better at pretending
And maybe we'll meet again somewhere
Somewhere things don't have to have an ending

You held my hand
You taught me love
And then you set me free
That's not such an awful ending
If we have to have an ending
Is this our maybe happy ending? 
We'll see

What is most interesting about the show is what happens AFTER that song is sung. 

The show does a beautiful job of weaving in questions about our relationship with technology and the idea that we are maybe turning ourselves into machines and ignoring our humanity. 

Criss and Shen have a monumental job performing this show eight times a week. Both are onstage practically the entire time (I started to get concerned for them going number after number after number with not so much as half a second offstage to get a quick sip of water.) They are joined by a small ensemble who play all the other roles in the show, but it is heavy lifting for Criss and Shen. Chriss' physicality is especially impressive and he's now my personal odds on favorite to win the Tony this year, as is the score of this show, and possibly Arden's direction. 

All the design elements are home runs, and special props must be given to the orchestra who appear onstage for just one number, complete with a turn table and those beautiful fireflies, and then must get back in the pit in time for the next song. 

These are the songs you're going to be hearing at every audition and musical theater class for the foreseeable future. This is an intelligent, beautiful show that is well worth checking out (they also have great rush and lottery options.) I highly recommend checking it out.

"Maybe Happy Ending" is currently running at the Belasco Theater on Broadway


John Davis


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE OPPOSITE OF LOVE - Hudson Theatre (Off-Broadway show makes it's L.A. Premiere)

If "The Opposite of Love" doesn't make Ashley Griffin a star, there is no justice in the world.  I had the opportunity to see the off-Broadway premiere of the show last spring (though I did not review that production) and when I found out I would be in town for its L.A. debut, I had to make sure I saw it. This is a brand new production - the only hold over is Ashley Griffin (the author of the piece) reprising her role as Eloise.  I was (and am) a huge fan of the off-Broadway production. It was one of the best things I'd seen in a long time, and I'm still frustrated that it didn't transfer to a longer NYC run. I was nervous when I heard that the show would have a brand new team, but, I have to say, for me, this new production is, at least at the moment, the definitive one. As much as I loved the show off-Broadway, the L.A. production reveals elements of the original that weren't as strong as they could have been. I didn't think it could get much better ...

OUR TOWN on Broadway

                                                                                             The cast of OUR TOWN , Daniel Rader I didn't know it was possible to make so many terrible decisions about this beautiful piece. OUR TOWN is widely considered not just one of the greatest American plays, but one of the greatest plays ever written. Experimental for its time, Thornton Wilder's piece, written in 1938, uses an all but bare stage and mimed action to examine the very nature of human existence. Divided into three "acts" (in practical terms the show is an hour and a half with no intermission... these "act" breaks do not denote actual breaks...) "Daily Life", "Love and Marriage" and "Death and Eternity", a Stage Manager takes us through the everyday lives o...

SWEPT AWAY on Broadway

                                            The company of Swept Away , photo by Emilio Madrid "Swept Away", now playing at the Longacre Theater on Broadway is...frustrating. It's the kind of piece that annoys theatergoers, and especially industry insiders, to no end. A musical that seemingly came out of nowhere (it had a successful production at Arena stage just before opening on Broadway) with marketing that tells us less than nothing about the show except that the ocean is in someway involved. One hopes that it's vague origins equate to a "diamond in the rough" piece... that rare original musical that caught the attention of a talented, intelligent producer and got it's "big break." Sadly, that's not what I saw at the Longacre. Dig a little deeper and you'll find that "Swept Away" was simply a "bee in the bonnet" passion project of the lead producer. One need only look at the...